Having watched so many isekais now, I think I know what makes me like it as a genre but kinda dislike some series on varying degrees. And it’s commitment to character personality.
I love My Next Life as Villainess not because of the plot or anything new and mindblowing the series does or doesn’t, but because they’re committed to Catarina being super intent on gaming her story to a good ending but also being just absolutely clueless and not managing to intentionally do anything.
And I didn’t like Why Raelina Ended Up at the Dukes Mansion quite as much because while the series depicts her as capable and brave, making these game of chess comparisons in her thinking, they suddenly reduce her to the level of absolutely clueless like Catarina when the plot requires it.
And why I prefer So I’m a Spider, So What to That Time I Got Reincarnated As a Slime, because Slime/Rimuru doesn’t show much aptitude for strategy or thinking outside “oh so that’s what it does, huh?”, he just gets these OP powers because the story wouldn’t advance if he didn’t. And once he’s powerful, he’s suddenly this strategic genius, whose trick still seems to be to keep the best thing hidden from even the viewer/reader until he’s literally at 1hp.
While Kumoko ponders on all her skill choices and even keeps some stuff un-updated because she just doesn’t know what they do. She thinks about everything she does and acts according to her gamer personality. Which is incidentally also why I absolutely LOVE Log Horizon.


























